They carry the lady mommy so you’re able to an area right away from toilet and you will Jenna claims it is at that time, she takes a cord-free cellular phone out-of the lady mom’s dressing area, and you may reconnects with the 911 operator
Fitzpatrick thinks Jenna drops the telephone and also the telephone call grabs, mere seconds later on, the particular minute when she very first observes her mother: since the Dr. It’s following she lets loose a-cry from pure anguish:
«Because the bland because it’s to learn, it’s inconceivable you to definitely that telephone call are anything apart from an effective declaration out-of guilt against their father,» told you Fitzpatrick.
But the safeguards says an identical telephone call proves Dr. Neulander’s innocence —when Jenna runs into the https://datinghearts.org/bumble-review/ toilet, there isn’t any blood towards the wall space yet. Jenna testifies she registers the telephone by bathroom, drops it since it is not performing while rushing to greatly help this lady dad. Throughout the shelter evaluate, this is when Jenna observes blood into the, and you can up to, her mother. That is where she yells, «There is bloodstream almost everywhere. «
«The fresh defense’s take on that is one their mommy is available, in front of her, and you will the woman is reacting to their mommy, the fresh new blood that is on her behalf mother and maybe blood on the wall surface as well as on the floor as well,» told you Stevens.
«One to aids the notion the first-time she saw blood, she is actually deciding on her mother,» Axelrod detailed in order to Stevens.
The new D.An effective, in the event, does not faith Jenna you will try everything she claims to have inked when you look at the 13 seconds the fresh 911 phone call was to the hold. Fitzpatrick tried it himself and claims they got him regarding 50 seconds.
There was one other element of Jenna’s testimony that may be very important. She informs this new jury you to as the girl father try looking after her mom on the rooms, she spotted him stop a bloodstream-soaked shirt and you will throw it aside. Today consider, the fresh safety ideal one to organizing this soft top could have triggered a number of the bloodstream splatter in the bed room. Although clothing is never located.
«She’d state zero,» Fitzpatrick told you. «I do not consider in her own head Jenna thinks you to definitely their father performed which. In my opinion she’s authored a protective business in her head where mom slipped and you may fell regarding bath.»
«I’m alarmed that they’re with a difficult reaction to the newest misery with the woman. . They know that the lady desires these to vote not liable. And so they remember that that it 60-plus-year-dated offender are unlikely to help you reoffend,» Fitzpatrick explained. «And all of those attitude can enjoy toward detriment out of circumstances that become shown past a good doubt.»
The fresh new Verdict
Just after 7 intense days of testimony, Region Lawyer Bill Fitzpatrick handled brand new jury one final time for closing objections, asking them to seriously consider the newest actual evidence — specifically brand new bloodstream spatter to the wall space and injuries in order to Leslie Neulander’s muscles.
«Whenever i said a couple of times regarding demo, Leslie usually talk to your, females and you may gentlemen. You have got to tune in to the girl,» the guy told Axelrod. «Also to plus pay attention cautiously on the words from Jenna Neulander for the reason that vital 911 phone call.»
But there is however something new D.An excellent. couldn’t give the fresh jury: exactly what he suspects try the new motive you to delivered Robert Neulander into a beneficial murderous anger that morning. Detectives learned regarding a friend of one’s Neulander nearest and dearest you to Leslie is actually considering finalizing a rental to own another apartment into the the day she died.
«Leslie was on her way out. Referring to maybe not a man that will manage one to,» Fitzpatrick informed Axelrod.